Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Updating this review from a while back with very positive results! We went back to this location and actually dined in, was a treat and had a great time. Family friendly atmosphere and super friendly service, casual place with a lot to offer.

The pizzas this time were cooked exceptionally well, tell tale markers of having been coal fired but not charred. Our party had the eggplant Marino and the hot honey pies- both delicious. We also ordered garlic knots - dripping with butter and garlic and Parmesan goodness. And of course their signature Anthony's wings. All fantastic as I know them to be, great flavor and well prepared. Less exciting to most people but not to me, also ordered the Italian salad. Crisp and fun :) definitely recommend it to balance out a heavy meal.

Glad we gave them another shot, and will be back again to be sure. If you're looking for a good pizza place that has more to offer than just pies, I do recommend them. And if you have a bad experience rest assured it is not their norm, and they pride themselves on correcting it. Couldn't ask for more. (Literally).

Causal pizza place. Food is decent. Hubby and I had an extra thick cut pepperoni pizza with hot honey oil. Meh. It wasn't hot nor spicy for us. It was interesting but it would need either to be spicy or hot to counter that honey sweetness.

For me, it was a thick crust pizza. Ho eh was okay with it, but I am not a fan of thick crust. It was doughy and not cooked in the center.

Service was okay. We sat at the bar area.

Place is quiet and well lite. Nice decor.

Nice little place. The dining area is not jammed with tables so you can have some privacy when talking. Wait staff are on top of things. Our soft drinks never emptied and they checked on us often.

My wife and I shared the chop salad. We also got the wings with garlic and Parmesan and they were really good. This was followed up with a 12" pizza with pepperoni and anchovies and the pizza was also very good.

Remember the pizzas are wood fired which have a tendency to get the crust edges a bit charred which we like. They even have a sign that says "our pizzas are well done." We would certainly come back here when in the area.

Pizza was cooked perfectly, and generous on the toppings! Wings were some of the best I've ever had, nice char and the grilled onions make them! Pickup was ready exactly when they said it would be. Overall a yummy meal and will return!

Great service. Great food. Try the garlic knots. You will love them. They're delicious!

After working all week, we opted to go out Friday night for dinner and haven't been here in a really long time and after eating all the great food remember we needed to come back more often. Met some friends had a lovely view of some ducklings outside, which was fun as well. We ordered the roast chicken wings which were delightful. I ordered a small white pie with garlic. Could've used a little bit more ricotta cheese but was tasty. The rest of the family opted for the pepperoni hot honey, which was actually very good. Service was excellent. Drinks were refilled quickly. Everyone did a great job in the kitchen a must return to.
Join the club get extra points go here once a week that's our pledge.

After years of faithful custom here I walked out tonight. Not because the food has become bad - it's still very good. However the service at the Carrollwood store has diminished over the past year. I have experienced very lengthy wait times for carry out. Tonight after planning to dine in we ran up against a very surly and inefficient greeter and really slow response times. As a result we walked. I hope the management does better in the future.

Best Pizza in town.
Great Food .. Friendly Staff... Great Service
100% Recommend Carrollwood Anthony's

Anthony's catered the food for my end of semester class party at USF. The pizza at Anthony's is nothing short of phenomenal. The coal-fired crust gives it that perfect charred crispiness while still maintaining a light and airy texture. And the toppings? Fresh, flavorful, and generously piled on top. The Paulie pizza was absolutely amazing! Thank you Anthony's for providing great service and great pizza for our end of year party after a long semester.

We were in the "neighborhood" after a massage and we were starving. Literally, like a bar signal,the smell of garlic alerted us that we were in near proximity to something delicious.

Anthony's has been on our list of places to try, but somehow we just never seem to make it to that side of town. Let me tell you, the pizza we ate makes Anthony's destination worthy.

We started with garlic knots and saved the garlic butter into which we dipped our pizza crusts. Needless to say no vampires visited us last night.

Table after table ordered the wings. I wish we had eaten them, but now we have an excuse to come back and try other menu items.

We noticed a line of vehicles along the sidewalk when we arrived, they have really got takeout curbside delivery down to a science.

Whether dine in or take home, Anthony's is 100% a must visit.