Shopping Discussion

RANT: I will NEVER go to Formula Honda (Markham Rd & Finch) EVER again

  • Last Updated:
  • Aug 6th, 2015 1:35 pm
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 17, 2005
9535 posts
12523 upvotes

RANT: I will NEVER go to Formula Honda (Markham Rd & Finch) EVER again

So the following happened about two weeks ago, and it's been bothering me still to the point that I really want to post it here. Its been bothering me because I have to pass by their location nearly every day and just seeing their dealership just reminds me of what happened and re-pisses me off.

So here's the story:

A couple weeks ago I notice A5 (I think) maintenance code on my dash, which equates to Coolant Change time. So, as I mention above, since I pass by Formula Honda (Markham rd and Finch) daily, I decide to quickly drop in and pickup a jug of Honda OEM coolant. All is well, I go in, get what I need, get out and later on drain and replace the coolant in my car. I try to reset the maintenance code using my ODB dongle but fail to figure out how, dont think much of it and just leave it as is, since it doesn't really bother me.

Fast forward approx a week later, oil life 10% indicator appears, I decide that since I was able to learn and do my own coolant change, I might as well try out doing an oil change myself. Takes me approx half a week to buy the oil, jack, jackstands, oil filter etc. (oil non OEM), by that time oil life is down to 5%. I dont mind its not at 0% so I change it and no problems. Again the same thing with the coolant change, I don't bother resetting the oil life indicator.

The next time I pass by the dealership it occurred to me that they could probably reset the A5 and Oil change indicators for me since I did buy the entire jug of coolant from them. I drive in, and idle infront of the dealership to find the original sales page/receipt for the coolant, at which point the technician at the drive through maintance bay notices me and motions me to drive in. I drive in, park and just quickly explain to the technician that I bought a jug of coolant from them and also did an oil change myself, and was wondering if they could do me a quick favour and reset the code (showing him my original receipt for the coolant). He said sure its very simple, no problem, just go into the service department and just get their OK first. So I turn off the car, go into the dealership and explain the situation to the service rep and show him the receipt. He looks at it, confirms the date of purchase then flat out says NO. I ask him why, and he tells me its because I didn't do the oil change with them. Im like.... OK..... then can you please just reset just the A5 Change Coolant Maintenance notification, since I did buy the coolant from them. He says NO again. Again I ask why.... he says because its one action to reset both codes at the same time. At that point I stare at him blankly, while going WTF in my mind and I say, so you would help me with the A5 code b/c I bought the coolant from you, but because, it just so happens, I did my oil change myself then you wont help me, even though it's one action. He replies YES, then adds, its very simple just go on youtube or something.

I'm like, fine and leave (thinking to myself ill just go to the regular mechanic I deal with and he'll do it for me), as I go to my car, the technician asks me if they authorized it, and I just tell him they said no because I didnt do both the oil change and coolant flush with you guys. We both stare blankly at each other, and im like yeah, thank you personally for your efforts anyways, and then proceed to drive off. When I get to my destination and wait for the person I was picking up to come out, I quickly decide to google the method on how to reset the codes on my dash. I find out that it had nothing to do with the ODB and all I needed to do was hold a button on the dash of the car for like 10 seconds and it would reset. At that point I get extremely pissed and annoyed with the previous situation, because what I was requesting was so SIMPLE to do, to the point that he COULD HAVE JUST TOLD ME what I needed to do.

This is why I WILL NEVER give Formula Honda any Maintenance Business or Purchase a Car from them EVER.


I'd rather drive the extra KMs and go to Markham Honda (Kennedy and 7) as their service totally eclipses Formula Honda several hundred-fold. Anecdotally last year I went to Markham Honda to buy a replacement philips headlight bulb from them and tried to change it myself, in their parking lot. For the hell of me, I couldn't figure out how to do it, so I ask a technician, which just so happens to be passing by, if he can direct me on what to do. He says, don't worry about it... just drive your car into the service bay and ill do it for you. Im like really? he's like yeah, just drive in. He spends some time and has some difficulty doing it b/c as I then learn, they have to go through the wheelwell to change the bulb. But at the end it's done. I ask him how much and he just shakes his head and said dont worry about it. I thank him for his time and effort, then go across to the Shell, get him a drink , drop it off and continue with my day. This is not the only time Markham Honda has far exceeded my expectations with their excellent service .

THE END.
47 replies
Deal Guru
User avatar
Sep 8, 2007
11172 posts
14843 upvotes
Way Out of GTA
Oh please. You know dealerships are a business right? All you bought was a measley jug of coolant from the PARTS dept...did the service YOURSELF and now you expect the SERVICE depts free advice on how to finish the job off? He actually gave you the answer...look on YouTube. So the info to reset it was right at your fingertips. How much time would you have saved just searching for it yourself? You should be boycotting yourself for wasting everyone's time.

What's next should they run a scanner on your OBD codes for free because you bought a jug of coolant? Maybe a wash and polish?

Your whole whiney statement and diatribe will get no one new to boycott Formula Honda.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 17, 2005
9535 posts
12523 upvotes
No I asked them to help me do something that was RELATED to what I bought from them (they make more than enough extra money on "OEM Products"). And BTW your example of ODB codes b/c I bought coolant makes absolutely no sense.

Yes he told me to go look on Google, but he could have just as easily as said, oh... all you need to do is hold the button for 10 seconds.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jan 3, 2014
3252 posts
3030 upvotes
Vancouver(ish)
Wizard1 wrote: No I asked them to help me do something that was RELATED to what I bought from them (they make more than enough extra money on "OEM Products"). And BTW your example of ODB codes b/c I bought coolant makes absolutely no sense.

Yes he told me to go look on Google, but he could have just as easily as said, oh... all you need to do is hold the button for 10 seconds.
As Cartfan has written, they told you where you could get your information. Your expectation that they tell you exactly what to do is unreasonable (if they do that for you, they should do it for everyone, and they'll not make any money) and would open them up to legal liability if something went wrong with the car during the reset procedure. Imagine this scenario (purely hypothetical and likely technically incorrect): You push the button, but it's the wrong button. Your display goes blank and odometer resets to zero and can't be put back to the correct number. Now, your car is broken and you sue because the technician didn't give you clear instructions on which button to press.

For the same reason an electrician won't tell you how to install outlets yourself in case your house burns down because you did the wiring incorrectly, this guy (either because of company policy or because he didn't want to risk it) and many other professionals won't tell you the solution. They will either provide you with the service or point you to a place that will give you the information you need but distances them from any liability.

You wanted free advice from a commercial enterprise. Your expectation was unreasonable and unrealistic.
Proud RFD member since January 31, 2007. Feel free to add 3,034 to my post count.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 17, 2005
9535 posts
12523 upvotes
Perhaps the main point has been lost in the long story. He said he would be more than willing to do it (because I had the original receipt), had I not done the oil change. So if I had not said anything about the oil change he would have did it. However regardless if the oil change was mentioned or not the process would have been the same. THAT is the reason I am upset.

You're over thinking it,its a button that resets the odometer (and if you hold it long enough it resets the maintenance indicator). It is NOT mission critical nor will it reset the entire car or cause it to fail

You're both making it sound like I'm asking for a huge expensive freebie but in fact I'm just asking for followup service for a item I purchased from them. By the same logic they should just tell you to figure out everything about your car yourself, once you drive it off the lot.

This is also why I give my business to places like Home Depot, the are more than willing to provide follow up advice to you whether you buy anything from them or not. And no I don't just randomly go in ask for advice and leave, it's usually after I bought something from them and for some reason am having difficulty
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Sep 19, 2002
7959 posts
9426 upvotes
Vancouver
Wizard1 wrote: Again I ask why.... he says because its one action to reset both codes at the same time. At that point I stare at him blankly, while going WTF in my mind and I say, so you would help me with the A5 code b/c I bought the coolant from you, but because, it just so happens, I did my oil change myself then you wont help me, even though it's one action. He replies YES, then adds, its very simple just go on youtube or something.
FYI, the dealer can reset individual maintenance items with their computer.
Deal Addict
Sep 30, 2008
1589 posts
202 upvotes
Liability, they don't want to touch your car unless you bring it in.

They could have handled it in a much more customer friendly way thou, but that's what you get when you hire high school dropouts (joking) and don't pay them well.

Which is why I hate dealing with dealerships. You can't really expect much from them, I suggest you lower your expectations of them and just DIY and Google things like this before wasting your time with them.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 17, 2005
9535 posts
12523 upvotes
That it's true, for some reason it didn't occur to me to check online, even though I found out how to flush the coolant and change the oil online.

Most stuff I usually do myself unless I absolutely can't figure it out. I'll just choose to go to Markham Honda instead as they have been more than willing to give advice and help me out
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jan 3, 2014
3252 posts
3030 upvotes
Vancouver(ish)
Wizard1 wrote: You're over thinking it,its a button that resets the odometer (and if you hold it long enough it resets the maintenance indicator). It is NOT mission critical nor will it reset the entire car or cause it to fail
You're missing the point. It makes no difference if it's "mission critical". If they tell you what to do and something goes sideways (even if you did it wrong and the problem had nothing do with what the directions they gave) they can be open to legal trouble.
He said he would be more than willing to do it (because I had the original receipt), had I not done the oil change.
...so there you go. He could not reset the system because it would clear both codes, and they cannot confirm the oil change was done correctly or to specifications. While you seem to raise this point in reply to my post to support your comments, it actually supports my earlier statement. If I had a Honda, I would actually take it to this company now because I know their staff do things by the book. Sure, it may be just to protect themselves legally, but it's by the book anyway. Well done Formula Honda.
You're both making it sound like I'm asking for a huge expensive freebie but in fact I'm just asking for followup service for a item I purchased from them.
...and that "followup service" has nothing to do with the item you purchased from them. "How to do I put this coolant into the car?" would be followup service. The reset button for the repair indicator is not connected to your purchase of coolant. It wasn't a huge expensive freebie - I don't think anyone has said it was. But you went into a business expecting a freebie and then when you didn't get it, you slag the business just because they didn't want to help you finish off your DIY project.

Thank you for providing all the detail. People can see that your rant is misplaced and unreasonable.
Proud RFD member since January 31, 2007. Feel free to add 3,034 to my post count.
Deal Expert
Jan 7, 2002
30060 posts
29731 upvotes
Waterloo, ON
First, I'd give my head a shake and my ass a shift kick for not asking Dr Google first: https://www.google.ca/webhp?q=how%20to% ... da%20civic

Or maybe even simpler, RTFM. The Owner's Manual of my Honda Civic devotes several pages to explaining the Maintenance Minder feature, including two pages on resetting it after an oil change.

You could have learned how to do it yourself in a fraction of the time it took to ask a dealer, let alone how long it took to post about it here.

Second, FWIW when I lived in the GTA I had just the opposite experience from yours with Formula Honda (good) and Markham Honda (bad.) You can't make any blanket inferences about a dealer, good or bad, based on a single experience.
veni, vidi, Visa
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 17, 2005
9535 posts
12523 upvotes
...so there you go. He could not reset the system because it would clear both codes, and they cannot confirm the oil change was done correctly or to specifications. While you seem to raise this point in reply to my post to support your comments, it actually supports my earlier statement. If I had a Honda, I would actually take it to this company now because I know their staff do things by the book. Sure, it may be just to protect themselves legally, but it's by the book anyway.
That doesnt make any sense, they are not liable regarding the oil change because they didn't do it in the first place. Furthermore there isn't any type of log on WHO cleared the oil change notification, like I said it's just the reset odometer button, it doesnt do anything BUT reset the odometer (or if you hold it long enough reset the maintenance minders). The car is out of warranty it doesnt matter who changes the oil, nor does resetting the indicator certify that things were done correctly or to specifications.
...and that "followup service" has nothing to do with the item you purchased from them. "How to do I put this coolant into the car?" would be followup service.
It has everything to do with the item I purchased from them as it would be the next logical step after your above question, and THAT, which I might point out, WOULD open them up to liability.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Jan 3, 2014
3252 posts
3030 upvotes
Vancouver(ish)
Wizard1 wrote: That doesnt make any sense, they are not liable regarding the oil change because they didn't do it in the first place.
One day...maybe one day...you'll grasp the concept. The oil change has nothing to do with it. The coolant change has nothing to do with it. You were expecting them to reset a maintenance warning light for an oil issue. They reset it and then your engine blows up. You say "well, it was THEY who reset the engine light, so I didn't know there was going to be a problem..." and hey, presto, they're on the hook for a bunch of legal fees and potentially actual damages.
It has everything to do with the item I purchased from them as it would be the next logical step after your above question...
Er, no. You bought a bottle of coolant, that you may or may not have put into your car (you could have poured it out to poison a few cats for all they know, or given it to your next door neighbour, for some examples). Buying a stand-alone bottle of product does not warrant being told how to reset a warning light. In this case, it did (according to your original post) but because there was another warning light that would be reset at the same time as the coolant warning, your coolant purchase was irrelevant.
...and THAT, which I might point out, WOULD open them up to liability.
No more than your expecting them to reset a warning light when they can't confirm that the work was done or was done to specifications, and based on my experience with contract law and liability, I would say substantially less.

You were wrong to expect this service for free. They very well may have done it if you had supporting documentation for the oil change, but you didn't. That's not their problem, it's yours for not providing it.

The dealership did absolutely nothing wrong in this case.
Proud RFD member since January 31, 2007. Feel free to add 3,034 to my post count.
Deal Guru
User avatar
Sep 8, 2007
11172 posts
14843 upvotes
Way Out of GTA
ALLCAPS wrote:

...and that "followup service" has nothing to do with the item you purchased from them. "How to do I put this coolant into the car?" would be followup service. The reset button for the repair indicator is not connected to your purchase of coolant. It wasn't a huge expensive freebie - I don't think anyone has said it was. But you went into a business expecting a freebie and then when you didn't get it, you slag the business just because they didn't want to help you finish off your DIY project.

Thank you for providing all the detail. People can see that your rant is misplaced and unreasonable.
And it appears this wasn't the first time. Last time he bought a bulb, tried to put it in himself and failed. While someone at a dealership did help on that occasion...it's now turned into an expected perk of buying a cheap part at a dealership. He expects DIY prices but with free advice from experts.

Formula Honda has nothing to fear from this rant and others will get a chuckle that a freeloader got stopped in his tracks...only to be made worse by coming on here and playing victim.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 25, 2001
5067 posts
774 upvotes
Toronto
Wizard1 wrote: No I asked them to help me do something that was RELATED to what I bought from them (they make more than enough extra money on "OEM Products"). And BTW your example of ODB codes b/c I bought coolant makes absolutely no sense.

Yes he told me to go look on Google, but he could have just as easily as said, oh... all you need to do is hold the button for 10 seconds.
So you wanted something for nothing. The time you took to write that rant, could easily google search or quickly read your manual. Its pretty sad folks expect freebies these days.
Deal Addict
Oct 18, 2007
4462 posts
1698 upvotes
ah... for a dealership to answer "just youtube it..." seems less then professional...

I have no issue with the dealership not offering to do anything because of oil change was done by the OP himself but "just go check online" is not something i'd expect from any company... that's like having foreign currency and asking a bank what the day's exchange rate is but and having them telling you "why don't you just check online for today's exchange?"

my parents went to Home Depot looking to buy a rubber ring to fix a faucet... the Home Depot staff just gave my parents the parts for free.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 25, 2001
5067 posts
774 upvotes
Toronto
tdott wrote: Liability, they don't want to touch your car unless you bring it in.

They could have handled it in a much more customer friendly way thou, but that's what you get when you hire high school dropouts (joking) and don't pay them well.

Which is why I hate dealing with dealerships. You can't really expect much from them, I suggest you lower your expectations of them and just DIY and Google things like this before wasting your time with them.
So they should provide information for free. Last time I check, you need quite a bit of knowledge to be a auto mechanic.
Deal Fanatic
User avatar
Apr 25, 2001
5067 posts
774 upvotes
Toronto
2 different situations. Please, I would tell him the same thing. Time is money, would it be better if they charged him for the advice. Just another freeloader who expect everything for free.
Deal Addict
User avatar
Dec 15, 2011
3049 posts
633 upvotes
Wizard1 wrote: So the following happened about two weeks ago, and it's been bothering me still to the point that I really want to post it here. Its been bothering me because I have to pass by their location nearly every day and just seeing their dealership just reminds me of what happened and re-pisses me off.

So here's the story:

A couple weeks ago I notice A5 (I think) maintenance code on my dash, which equates to Coolant Change time. So, as I mention above, since I pass by Formula Honda (Markham rd and Finch) daily, I decide to quickly drop in and pickup a jug of Honda OEM coolant. All is well, I go in, get what I need, get out and later on drain and replace the coolant in my car. I try to reset the maintenance code using my ODB dongle but fail to figure out how, dont think much of it and just leave it as is, since it doesn't really bother me.

Fast forward approx a week later, oil life 10% indicator appears, I decide that since I was able to learn and do my own coolant change, I might as well try out doing an oil change myself. Takes me approx half a week to buy the oil, jack, jackstands, oil filter etc. (oil non OEM), by that time oil life is down to 5%. I dont mind its not at 0% so I change it and no problems. Again the same thing with the coolant change, I don't bother resetting the oil life indicator.

The next time I pass by the dealership it occurred to me that they could probably reset the A5 and Oil change indicators for me since I did buy the entire jug of coolant from them. I drive in, and idle infront of the dealership to find the original sales page/receipt for the coolant, at which point the technician at the drive through maintance bay notices me and motions me to drive in. I drive in, park and just quickly explain to the technician that I bought a jug of coolant from them and also did an oil change myself, and was wondering if they could do me a quick favour and reset the code (showing him my original receipt for the coolant). He said sure its very simple, no problem, just go into the service department and just get their OK first. So I turn off the car, go into the dealership and explain the situation to the service rep and show him the receipt. He looks at it, confirms the date of purchase then flat out says NO. I ask him why, and he tells me its because I didn't do the oil change with them. Im like.... OK..... then can you please just reset just the A5 Change Coolant Maintenance notification, since I did buy the coolant from them. He says NO again. Again I ask why.... he says because its one action to reset both codes at the same time. At that point I stare at him blankly, while going WTF in my mind and I say, so you would help me with the A5 code b/c I bought the coolant from you, but because, it just so happens, I did my oil change myself then you wont help me, even though it's one action. He replies YES, then adds, its very simple just go on youtube or something.

I'm like, fine and leave (thinking to myself ill just go to the regular mechanic I deal with and he'll do it for me), as I go to my car, the technician asks me if they authorized it, and I just tell him they said no because I didnt do both the oil change and coolant flush with you guys. We both stare blankly at each other, and im like yeah, thank you personally for your efforts anyways, and then proceed to drive off. When I get to my destination and wait for the person I was picking up to come out, I quickly decide to google the method on how to reset the codes on my dash. I find out that it had nothing to do with the ODB and all I needed to do was hold a button on the dash of the car for like 10 seconds and it would reset. At that point I get extremely pissed and annoyed with the previous situation, because what I was requesting was so SIMPLE to do, to the point that he COULD HAVE JUST TOLD ME what I needed to do.

This is why I WILL NEVER give Formula Honda any Maintenance Business or Purchase a Car from them EVER.


I'd rather drive the extra KMs and go to Markham Honda (Kennedy and 7) as their service totally eclipses Formula Honda several hundred-fold. Anecdotally last year I went to Markham Honda to buy a replacement philips headlight bulb from them and tried to change it myself, in their parking lot. For the hell of me, I couldn't figure out how to do it, so I ask a technician, which just so happens to be passing by, if he can direct me on what to do. He says, don't worry about it... just drive your car into the service bay and ill do it for you. Im like really? he's like yeah, just drive in. He spends some time and has some difficulty doing it b/c as I then learn, they have to go through the wheelwell to change the bulb. But at the end it's done. I ask him how much and he just shakes his head and said dont worry about it. I thank him for his time and effort, then go across to the Shell, get him a drink , drop it off and continue with my day. This is not the only time Markham Honda has far exceeded my expectations with their excellent service .

THE END.
He did helped you.
Deal Addict
Apr 23, 2005
1437 posts
464 upvotes
Comparing the auto place to Home depot is ridiculous.

HD is all about helping "do It Yourself"..
Auto garages are not
Penalty Box
User avatar
Oct 19, 2012
3359 posts
421 upvotes
Toronto
No matter how you put it the idiot at the dealership should have told him how to reset the code, OP bought a Honda car FFS's and a Honda dealership just brushes him aside?

Top