Opinion The Student Debt Problem Is Worse Than We Imagined
Mr. Miller is the senior director for postsecondary education at the Center for American Progress.

13.1%

10%

Without any oversight,

the share of schools

with high default rates

rises sharply.

5

Share of colleges with

high default rates

Students begin repaying loans

and the Department of

Education begins tracking

default rates.

After three years,

the tracking

period ends.

2.1%

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

Share of colleges with

high default rates

13.1%

In 2012, students began

repaying loans and the Department

of Education began reporting

default rates.

After three years, that

tracking period ended.

10%

Without any oversight,

the share of schools

with high default rates

rose sharply.

5

Tracking

period

ends

2.1%

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

Note: “High” default rates are 30% or greater. Source: Department of Education

Millions of students will arrive on college campuses soon, and they will share a similar burden: college debt. The typical student borrower will take out $6,600 in a single year, averaging $22,000 in debt by graduation, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

There are two ways to measure whether borrowers can repay those loans: There’s what the federal government looks at to judge colleges, and then there’s the real story. The latter is coming to light, and it’s not pretty.

Consider the official statistics: Of borrowers who started repaying in 2012, just over 10 percent had defaulted three years later. That’s not too bad — but it’s not the whole story. Federal data never before released shows that the default rate continued climbing to 16 percent over the next two years, after official tracking ended, meaning more than 841,000 borrowers were in default. Nearly as many were severely delinquent or not repaying their loans (for reasons besides going back to school or being in the military). The share of students facing serious struggles rose to 30 percent over all.

Tracking period ends

Share of students

defaulting on loans

15.5%

10%

10.4%

Students begin

repaying loans

5

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

Share of students defaulting on loans

16%

Tracking

period ends

Students begin

repaying loans

10%

10.4%

5

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

Collectively, these borrowers owed over $23 billion, including more than $9 billion in default.

Nationally, those are crisis-level results, and they reveal how colleges are benefiting from billions in financial aid while students are left with debt they cannot repay. The Department of Education recently provided this new data on over 5,000 schools across the country in response to my Freedom of Information Act request.

The new data makes clear that the federal government overlooks early warning signs by focusing solely on default rates over the first three years of repayment. That’s the time period Congress requires the Department of Education to use when calculating default rates.

At that time, about one-quarter of the cohort — or nearly 1.3 million borrowers — were not in default, but were either severely delinquent or not paying their loans. Two years later, many of these borrowers were either still not paying or had defaulted. Nearly 280,000 borrowers defaulted between years three and five.

Federal laws attempting to keep schools accountable are not doing enough to stop loan problems. The law requires that all colleges participating in the student loan program keep their share of borrowers who default below 30 percent for three consecutive years or 40 percent in any single year. We can consider anything above 30 percent to be a “high” default rate. That’s a low bar.

Among the group who started repaying in 2012, just 93 of their colleges had high default rates after three years and 15 were at immediate risk of losing access to aid. Two years later, after the Department of Education stopped tracking results, 636 schools had high default rates.

24.9%

20

15

AVERAGE Default Rates

by school type

14.6%

13.5%

tracking

ends

10

10.6%

tracking

ends

8.5%

5

5.0%

tracking

ends

0

2012

‘13

‘14

‘15

‘16

‘12

‘13

‘14

‘15

‘16

‘12

‘13

‘14

‘15

‘16

Private nonprofit

Public college

Private for-profit

AVERAGE Default Rates by school type

Private

for-profit

24.9%

Tracking

ends

14.6%

Public

college

13.5%

10.6%

Private

nonprofit

8.5%

5.0%

2012

‘13

‘14

‘15

‘16

For-profit institutions have particularly awful results. Five years into repayment, 44 percent of borrowers at these schools faced some type of loan distress, including 25 percent who defaulted. Most students who defaulted between three and five years in repayment attended a for-profit college.

The secret to avoiding accountability? Colleges are aggressively pushing borrowers to use repayment options known as deferments or forbearances that allow borrowers to stop their payments without going into delinquency or defaulting. Nearly 20 percent of borrowers at schools that had high default rates at year five but not at year three used one of these payment-pausing options.

SHARE OF STUDENTS WITH DEFERMENTS OR IN DEFAULT

Among schools with high default rates in 2016 but not 2014

Deferments

43.4%

In default

34.4%

30%

Tracking period ends

20

10

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

SHARE OF STUDENTS WITH

DEFERMENTS OR IN DEFAULT

Among schools with high default

rates in 2016 but not 2014

Deferments

43.4%

In default

34.4%

Tracking

period

ends

30%

20

10

0

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

Note: Deferments exclude borrowers in the military or back in school. “High” default rates are 30% or greater. Source: Department of Education

The federal government cannot keep turning a blind eye while almost one-third of student loan borrowers struggle. Fortunately, efforts to rewrite federal higher-education laws present an opportunity to address these shortcomings. This should include losing federal aid if borrowers are not repaying their loans — even if they do not default. Loan performance should also be tracked for at least five years instead of three.

The federal government, states and institutions also need to make significant investments in college affordability to reduce the number of students who need a loan in the first place. Too many borrowers and defaulters are low-income students, the very people who would receive only grant aid under a rational system for college financing. Forcing these students to borrow has turned one of America’s best investments in socioeconomic mobility — college — into a debt trap for far too many.

Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook and Twitter (@NYTOpinion), and sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter.

Intelligent Discussion What are your thoughts?
Share