Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
A mother with her baby begging in Athens. The youth unemployment rate has reached 51% in Greece, compared with 16% in the UK.
A mother with her baby begging in Athens. The youth unemployment rate has reached 51% in Greece, compared with 16% in the UK. Photograph: Milos Bicanski/Getty
A mother with her baby begging in Athens. The youth unemployment rate has reached 51% in Greece, compared with 16% in the UK. Photograph: Milos Bicanski/Getty

Is Britain's debt really like Greece's?

This article is more than 8 years old

The chancellor compared the UK’s economy with that of Greece in his budget speech. Does George Osborne’s claim stand up or was it just political rhetoric?

Greece has featured several times in George Osborne’s narrative about the UK’s public finances. He likened Britain’s rising debt levels to those of Greece in his 2010 budget and repeated the same warning in his latest budget speech.

But while it was possible in 2010 to mention both countries in the same breath after they both had annual public spending deficits in double digits, the situation now is quite different.

Debt

Athens has accumulated a debt mountain of 175% of GDP compared with a UK debt total that is expected to hit 80% of annual income, which is comparable with France and Germany.

GDP

Britain’s GDP has recovered to a point where it is higher than in 2010, whereas the Greek economy remains 25% below where it was before the financial crash.

Unemployment

Unemployment in Britain and Greece was rising in 2010. However, the rate has since come down to 5.5% in the UK against a stubbornly high 25% in Greece and a youth unemployment rate of 51% that compares with 16% in the UK.

Interest rates

Greece cannot raise money on the international markets to finance its debts because if it tried, and let’s just say the current crisis is solved, the interest rate would be too high – at 20% or more. Britain’s status as a safe haven means it can raise 10-year bonds at an interest rate of about 2%.

Currency

Greece must rely on the European Central Bank to print euros if it runs short. Athens has found out the hard way that the support of the ECB can be limited when times are tough. Britain has its own central bank, which can be called upon to print money to get out of a sticky situation. The Bank of England has spent £375bn buying UK government bonds and is a key reason the UK is considered a safe haven.

More on this story

More on this story

  • Greek crisis: new bailout request filed – as it happened

  • Greece debt crisis: Athens accepts harsh austerity as bailout deal nears

  • Has George Osborne really introduced a living wage?

  • Greek crisis: Athens submits request for third bailout

  • Are UK roads really worse than Puerto Rico’s or Namibia’s?

  • Greek crisis: Government submits reform plan in bid for new aid deal - as it happened

  • Greek debt crisis: Tsipras gets ultimatum to reach deal or face Grexit - as it happened

  • Poorer than Greece: the EU countries that reject a new Athens bailout

  • Greece given days to agree bailout deal or face banking collapse and euro exit

  • Postcard from Patmos: ‘Come to Greece on holiday and don’t be afraid’

Most viewed

Most viewed