Nurse and Patient, Sharing Laughter

It’s the rare patient who copes with the stress of cancer by being a comedian, but a few people do. I have always found these patients not only funny, but fascinating.

One patient, a middle-aged woman, very thin, with an elfin face, got bad news on morning rounds. With the medical team at her bedside, she gestured toward the physician, then looked at Todd, her nurse for that shift, and asked in an innocent tone, “Does he know about our baby?”

Theresa BrownJeff Swensen for The New York Times Theresa Brown, R.N.

Todd said he turned every possible shade of red, but it was the kind of comment we’d all come to expect from this sardonic patient. She told us that she wanted her tombstone simply to list all the men with whom she’d ever been intimate. When one particularly somber doctor made his rounds, she scolded him for failing to order her a nightly martini.

We don’t need Freud to point out the unconscious desire expressed by this spirited middle-aged woman, who, faced with her own mortality, joked that she was still a sexually active party girl.

Another patient managed to find his own dark sense of humor in the midst of a dreadful chemotherapy session. The particular drug he needed required that I sit in the room and slowly inject it into his intravenous line. We call it “pushing chemo” because the drug comes in huge syringes that we use to literally push chemo into the patient’s veins. It takes about 20 minutes to get all the drug in, and during the process I was swathed in special blue plastic gowns that covered me from head to toe, and two layers of thick blue plastic gloves, to protect myself from this toxic drug that can blister skin.

Not only was the patient completely unprotected, but I was shooting the drug right into his veins. That paradox was not lost on him, and he called the chemotherapy “poison.” To heighten the sense of irony, the drug resembles orange soda in color and consistency, but all the checks and double-checks we go through before administering it show it is not that sweet drink from my childhood.

The patient had a female friend visiting, and they were watching a television program about a white supremacist group. While I sat there, pushing the chemo into his veins, he started riffing on how he was the only African-American member of the group. It wasn’t so much what he said as how he said it, and he had me laughing so hard I almost cried. It was, of course, an unsettling topic about which to joke, but maybe that’s why he chose it, venturing into forbidden humor as a way to cope with the unsettling circumstances of his treatment.

I remember another patient, a union organizer, who was hospitalized for treatment during the months just prior to the 2008 presidential election. I had evening shift that day, and the patient’s frustration grew as he watched coverage of the campaign on television. He saw the election as potentially historic, and wanted to be out campaigning. Instead, his cancer kept him stuck in a hospital bed.

He started telling a series of off-color jokes that I won’t repeat. I was busy caring for patients, but while I was out of the room he would think up a joke for me, and then tell me the joke the next time I came in. Each time the joke would be more outrageous, and each time he would say, “I really cleaned that one up for you.”

I suppose I should have been offended, but I wasn’t. I’ve never been in the hospital with cancer, but I’m pretty sure I would find it exhausting and terrifying. As coping strategies go, I could handle his racy humor just fine.

At the end of James Thurber’s short novel “The 13 Clocks,” a prince and princess have achieved a fairy-tale happy ending. They are advised to “Remember laughter. You’ll need it even in the blessed isles of Ever After.”

And that is what I like to remember from caring for these patients — the laughter. A patient and a nurse, sharing some laughs, lifting for a few hours the dark cloud created by disease.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

We laugh to keep the tears at bay and shake a stick at Death as if to distract him maybe long enough to get another love — or good line — in. There is nothing so hilarious as something that completely isn’t. Laugh though your heart is breaking — tell that to your cardiologist along with a good joke as you go under for bypass surgery.
Is it any wonder that some of the best comic lines happen at a wake– or funeral service? James Joyce’s bloody hilarious “Finnegans Wake” is but a long elaborate cat’s cradle of jokes about death and whatnot.
Anybody who missed the last hospice-ish days of Art Buchwald, Timothy Leary or Warren Zevon missed many dark belly laughs indeed.
The Grim Reaper is such a standard character in Cartooning that it’s use is practically a tea ceremony for the comic mind.
Doctors, nurses and patients all need the healing relief of the surprise of wit.
Sad facts will finally have their way and the Grim will Reap, but until then laugh, laugh against the dying of the light.

Opiates to an extent offer pain relief from the cancer pain. as a cancer patient found out that hydrocodone, vicodin in mild dosages will help overcome the chemotherapy that can sap the soul

I work in long term care and have had a few really funny Residents on hospice. One lady had decided to take off her oxygen and “just die”. She was tired of the problems. Her Doctor said it was her choice. I sat with her. Her Sa02 dropped slowly through the 80s, into the 70s, finally with her Sa02 at 66%, she opened one eye and said, “Its already 6 am, who is the next nurse coming in?” I told her the nurses’ name. She sat up, said, “Oh good Lord, she’ll be so busy she won’t help at all. Give me my 02, I’ll do this another day.”
Another time, a hospice Resident was wondering if she should start a patio garden, since she was weaker by the day. I knew her pretty well, and said, “If I were you, I wouldn’t even buy green bananas.” I heard her laughing ten minutes later when I was down the other end of the hall.
One guy, in pretty bad shape, I saw every day. I gave him a hug goodbye and he said, “Well, there’s my sex for the day.” lol.

There are a whole lot of little comments that they will say, some are so dry that it takes awhile before you realize what they are doing. Dying isn’t so bad if you consider it part of living.

I am a huge, HUGE believer in humor. Sometimes it’s the only power we have over dreadful things like cancer, and it was among my favored coping skills when I went through five surgeries for DCIS. I remember telling my oncologist “None that I know of” when he asked during our first consult if I had any children from a previous relationship. (I’m pretty sure I stole that from Ellen DeGeneres.) I would hope to do the same if I’m ever blessed with the chemo experience, which I’m sure is much tougher than anything I went through.

God bless your valiant patients and thank you for sharing this. P.S. Christopher Hitchens is also displaying some astutely wicked humor in his essays for Vanity Fair.

Jackie Fox
Author, From Zero to Mastectomy: What I Learned And You Need to Know About Stage 0 Breast Cancer

Nice try this article but no passing grade. All patients know that they are the loosers-of-the-day and just play along when the nurse early in the morning allways says:”and how are WE doing today.” Perhaps if the Queen of England is sick use the word ”WE” – but anyone else just say ”YOU” – unless the nurse has cancer too.

“We don’t need Freud to point out the unconscious desire expressed by this spirited middle-aged woman, who, faced with her own mortality, joked that she was still a sexually active party girl.”

I doubt Freud had anything to do with it. I’m guessing she just wanted to be incredibly silly in the face of some very dark moments.

When friends are sick, I often use humor to ease into conversations or to broach difficult subjects. “If you didn’t want to go on that trip with me, you could have just said so. You didn’t need to go and get cancer to get out of it!” Humor is my coping mechanism. I laugh with my friends so I can feel comfortable crying with them.

When I was diagnosed with Stage IV Ovarian cancer, I greatly appreciated any time that I could laugh. I don’t think we realize how somber we become when faced with news like that. And everyone we come in contact with can also be too serious, as if a smile or a laugh might somehow be thought to show that they do not understand the seriousness of the situation. I was diagnosed right before the 2008 election, and as a democrat, decided I would show my support by naming my ovaries Bush and Cheney. It was time for them to leave. It provided plenty of much needed laughter for all of us during a trying time.

I had a stem cell transplant for a very intense treatment against breast cancer a few years ago. In order to harvest the stem cells I had to be hooked for hours to a machine that took my blood spinned it around and removed the stem cells then pumped the blood back into me. Several patients were in the room undergoing this procedure and a nurse came in and asked very cheerfully “And how are we doing?” and I answered “We are having a bloody good time” and all the patients laughed at this silly retort.

I am a stage 4 lung cancer patient who has had 38 weeks of chemo and a lobe removed from one lung during the past 104 weeks. I joke with infusion nurses all the time about their wearing hazmat suits while they poison me.

I remembering calling 3 friends from my cell phone 2 hours after leaving recovery from my lobectomy to say no one had killed me yet. No one has forgotten receiving that call or laughing about having received it.

At work, people kindly tell me that I look good and if they did not know I was so sick they could not tell. In reply I say that, using a Billy Crystal line from the Princess Bride movie, I look and feel pretty good for a guy that’s almost mostly dead.

Why? Because I want to acknowledge the obvious and face it with disdain and move on. I’m running out of time too quickly to not see that there are absurdities all around.

And unlike most of you, I don’t have to worry about outliving my retirement savings. Or being politically correct. Or worrying that Paul Krugman is right.

FROM TPP — Thanks for sharing your story with us.

For the months of cancer treatment (after I was diagnosed just one year into my marriage), if I wanted some little favor from my husband, he would smile and tell me to do it myself. To which I would respond, “But I have cancer.” Soon, all I had to say was BIHC. Humor was a life-saver (literally, now 13 years later!) for me.

Rare? What else CAN you do? A good friend came with me and told me blonde jokes during my infusions & people thought it was weird… why? Was I supposed to sit there being bored? Life goes on. It is not always fun but that’s OK. You do what you have to. Somebody is always worse off than you are…

Over the summer I had 40 weeks of radiation treatments at the Dana Fraber Cancer Institute; the daily experience was exhausting and somewhat overwhelming. My humor and jokes kept all of us smiling through those tedious trips. I just treated each day as if it was a party I was attending. Everyone caring for me showed warmth and humor in return!

Honestly, I can’t find any humor in having cancer. But, I’d like to take this moment to thank all of the wonderful people who care for people like me. I have to say, that all of the people, beginning with the receptionists who greet us, down to the nurses and doctors who treat us, and all of the support personal in between, are AMAZING human beings. I marvel at how THEY wake up every morning, and come to work with a smile on THEIR faces and truly try to make us feel better…and smile! :)

This is why I hate the dentist. Verbal humor is lame.

My father kept his sense of humor to the end, literally. I feel it was a form of bravery, though based on our conversation the night before he died, I don’t think he realized death would claim him the next afternoon.

I watched him as he tried time and again to make the nurses laugh, but for the most part they were rushed and not attuned to an old man making jokes. And, he was funny if they had cared to listen. The doctors and nurses who really listen and acknowledge the humanity of their patients are doing God’s work.

Thank you for caring about your patients nurse Brown and sharing their stories, though I did find this one almost unbearably sad.

I think humor informs love.

Mildred (Mickey) Gittelson December 1, 2010 · 7:40 pm

I entertained my BOBUDDIES friends with my jokes about cancer.

“My oncologist takes my Breast away…..he leaves me breastless.

The information about avoiding breast cancer is very important.
If you keep abreast of this information….you can keep a breast.

“We don’t need Freud to point out the unconscious desire expressed by this spirited middle-aged woman, who, faced with her own mortality, joked that she was still a sexually active party girl.”

Jango (#6) replies: “I doubt Freud had anything to do with it.”

I’m with you on this, Jango – I don’t think it reflected any “unconscious desire” on the woman’s part, either. She was staking her claim as a funny, sexual being, no matter the ravages of age and/or her illness. Or is that supposed to be the exclusive province of the young and healthy? Party on, spirited middle-aged woman – and keep on making your male nurses blush!

Oh, and check out “The Big C” for a TV version of a spirited middle-aged woman who rejects “appropriate” cancer patient behavior!

Jack Rower (#10): I wish you could stick around, even though these are interesting times (as referenced in the Chinese curse). I’ll try to keep your outlook in mind the next time a doctor gives me news about another bodily betrayal!

Ms. Brown, in spite of the unnecessary slipping in of a Freudian reference, this is the best-written piece I’ve seen by you here in this blog. I like it when you focus more on your patients, and less on your reactions to hospital interactions gone awry. Give us more interesting stories! You’re an intelligent enough writer that we can “read between the lines” and figure out what you think of situations without your having to spell that out for us.

Laughter makes you healthy. Being optimistic and trying to take it as easy as you can will help your spirit in fighting the illness.

Doctors did not give any chance to my Dad, but he is still with us, fully functioning, these what made him fighting back his illness.
//www.lifestyle-after50.com

I have no choice about whether to laugh about cancer or not – my partner does things that make me laugh, regardless of how I feel. I was sitting watching television one night, without my wig. Suddenly I felt ‘thwack thwack’ against my head. Turned out to be my partner, hitting me with a teaspoon. He said, “you look so much like a boiled egg I thought I’d see if you cracked”.

Which doesn’t sound funny at all in print, but it had me howling with laughter at the time.

Or when I ask him one too many times to wait on me, he says, “got leg cancer, have you?”

I feel like the woman in a recent New Yorker cartoon: “I don’t mind tragic things happening to me, as long as I can turn them into a funny anecdote”.

My summer as a nurse’s aide in 1957 when I was 16, a patient introduced me to humor as a tool to influence and delight people when one was ill– and after being shocked I was thrilled. She was in her 80s, had congestive heart failure, and would call out to the people we passed when I pushed her wheelchair or when anyone entered her room, “Greetings and Sour Potatoes!”

She had a witty, intelligent routine that developed from that that got her and got the nursing staff through the day. And some of them were dark days.

Now at almost 70 myself, I remember her so clearly and her lesson has enlivened my life through my husband’s cancer treatments, and other medical emergencies.

Laughter is a gift from the gods. Use it or lose it.

I once sat with my mother while my father was being worked on in the ER (we already knew that he was dead and that EMS has taken him to a hospital as a courtesy to avoid waiting for the Medical Examiner’s office to send someone to the home to declare him dead) and out come a clerk with a plastic bag of his belongings: shoes, socks, watch, wallet.

I turned to my mother and, with dark humor, said, “Not a good sign!” I couldn’t help laugh.

Some sophisticated people simply bring a sense of humor to even the worst situations. Good for them!