New Erdogan powers 'huge threat' to democracy, warns HRW

New Erdogan powers 'huge threat' to democracy, warns HRW
Human Rights Watch has said that the constitutional changes pose a huge threat to human rights, the rule of law, and the country’s democratic future.
3 min read
18 January, 2017
The proposed changes will create an executive presidency for the first time in modern Turkey[Getty]

Plans to dramatically expand the powers of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan pose a "huge threat" to human rights, law and the country's democratic future, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said on Wednesday.

In a damning statement against changes to the Turkish constitution, the US-based rights watchdog said the bill going through parliament on Wednesday in its second reading would "concentrate unchecked power in the president's hands".

The proposed changes, which will create an executive presidency for the first time in modern Turkey, are controversial and far-reaching, with HRW claiming they would "weaken parliamentary oversight of the executive".

Proponents compare the system the government is pushing through as akin to that in France or the United States and necessary for effective government and to avoid the need for fragile coalition governments.

The president will have the power to appoint and fire ministers, while the post of prime minister will be abolished for the first time in Turkey's history and replaced by single or multiple vice presidents.

The president will have the power to appoint and fire ministers, while the post of prime minister will be abolished for the first time in Turkey's history and replaced by single or multiple vice presidents

Late Sunday, the parliament backed the two final sections of the 18-article new constitution after a marathon week of debating that began on January 9 and included sessions that often lasted late into the night.

The articles will again be debated and if approved by at least 330 votes in the 550-seat assembly, a referendum could take place as soon as the start of April.

The president and the parliament would also together be able to choose four members of the 17-strong Supreme Board of Judges and Prosecutors (HSYK), a key judicial council that appoints and removes personnel in the judiciary. The parliament would choose seven members on its own.

Erdogan criticised the current system on Wednesday during a speech in Ankara, saying the new system "redefining relations between the legislative, executive and judicial powers with a democratic understanding would not be a loss for Turkey but a great gain", without giving further details.

But Hugh Williamson, HRW Europe and Central Asia director, said the changes would "further erode already weak checks and balances on the exercise of that power".

He urged parliament to reject the changes that "would hollow out the rule of law, and profoundly undermine the country’s democracy".

The watchdog criticised the government rushing through a bill during a state of emergency and accused it of restricting public debate while dozens of media outlets had been shut down.

The emergency has been in place since the attempted overthrow of Erdogan last summer.